Guy at the parts counter talked me out of the $60 gasket kit and he was dead wrong
I popped into the NAPA on Route 9 near my place to grab a valve cover gasket set for my 2004 Tacoma, and the older guy behind the counter said to skip the kit and just smear on some RTV sealant, cheaper and faster. I went with it because he had 30 years on me and I was short on cash that Friday. Two weeks and 400 miles later the truck was leaking oil all over my driveway and the leak got bad enough that I had to top off a quart before work. Pulled the cover off and the RTV had squeezed out and clogged a couple of the bolt holes, so I ended up doing the whole job twice. Has anyone else taken counter advice that cost you double the work?
Thirty years behind the counter and he still told you to skip a $60 kit for a tube of RTV on a 2004 Tacoma with a 2TR-FE. Hate to break it to you but that guy was mostly right and the leak was on you. Toyota ships those valve covers from the factory with sealant at the corners and around the cam caps, it's right there in the service manual, so RTV is not some shade tree shortcut. The real trick is a fresh gasket with a thin bead of Toyota FIPG at those six spots and letting it skin over before you torque the cover down in the right sequence. You said it yourself, the RTV squeezed out and clogged the bolt holes, which means you laid it on thick and cranked it down wet. A $60 kit doesn't save you from that. The counter guy gave you solid advice and you just did the job wrong.