Vent: My lentil soup turned into a weird paste and I'm not sure why

I followed a recipe for a basic lentil soup from a blog, aiming to make a big pot for under five bucks. I used brown lentils, an onion, a couple carrots, and a box of vegetable broth. Everything seemed fine until about an hour in when I checked on it. Instead of a nice brothy soup, it was a thick, almost gluey paste. I think I messed up the liquid ratio. The recipe said 6 cups of broth for a pound of lentils, but I guess my lentils soaked up way more than expected. I tried to thin it out with more water, but the flavor got really weak. Now I have a giant container of bland lentil mush. Anyone have a foolproof method for getting the texture right on lentil soup so it stays soupy?

3 comments

3 Comments

robin39614d ago

Yeah, that gluey paste thing is so common with brown lentils. I read somewhere they just keep drinking up liquid forever if you let them. My trick is to start with way more broth than it seems like you need, like almost double what the recipe says, and keep a kettle of hot water nearby to top it up as it cooks. Also, adding a splash of vinegar or lemon juice at the end brightens everything back up if you have to water it down.

blair8958d ago

Robin396 is totally right about them just drinking forever. I had that happen once and my whole kitchen smelled like wet cement. The thing nobody talks about is the heat level. If you have it at a full rolling boil the whole time, it breaks down the lentils way faster into that starchy paste. After you bring it up to a boil, try turning it down to the lowest simmer you can get. It takes longer but they hold their shape better and you get more of a soup than a porridge.

grayperez14d ago

Robin396 is overcomplicating it, just follow the recipe and don't let it overcook. That paste means you boiled it way too long.