Loading…
-1
Our book club spent two hours arguing about a character's hair color
We were discussing a fantasy novel last month, and a huge fight broke out over whether the main character's hair was described as 'auburn' or 'copper red'. We all had different print editions. We spent a full 90 minutes reading passages out loud, checking online, and even emailing the publisher. It turned out the UK and US versions used different words. Has your group ever gotten stuck on a tiny detail like that?
3 comments
Log in to join the discussion
Log In3 Comments
the_matthew5mo ago
Spend two hours on hair color and I'd be tempted to dye my own hair gray from frustration! That's the most book club thing I've ever heard, but I totally get it. Once you get locked on a tiny detail like that, you just can't let it go. The fact it was a regional edition difference makes it even funnier, like a secret literary prank on readers. My old group once nearly came to blows over whether a sandwich mentioned in a scene had pickles.
6
jessica_dixon4mo ago
My book club spent a full hour debating whether the author INTENDED for the heroine's scarf to be cashmere or if it was just a generic 'soft wrap.' We found proof in the author's old blog where she mentioned her grandma knit it from a specific alpaca farm. Three people brought printouts. The meeting was supposed to end at 8 but we went until 9:15 over ALPACA.
6
rowan1095mo ago
But honestly, the_matthew, are we sure this stuff matters? Getting that worked up over pickle inclusion or hair color feels like missing the forest for the trees. The point is the story, not the garnish on a fictional sandwich. I've seen groups waste a whole meeting on if a character's eyes were blue or green, while ignoring the actual themes. It just seems like a weird way to avoid talking about the book's real meaning.
1