I had to pick between a new anvil or a new forge this spring
My old anvil had a sway back and the forge was rusting out, but I only had about $800 saved. I went with the NC Tools anvil because I found a good deal at the trade show in Lexington. It's made a huge difference in my hammer control and the shoes come out cleaner. Anyone else had to make a tough call between two big tools?
But what if your anvil is so broken it ruins the work? @violafox, a bad forge makes heating hard, but a bad anvil can wreck a good heat. You need both tools to be solid.
Totally get where you're coming from. A messed up anvil face can really trash a piece. Seen it happen. You get a perfect heat and then the metal just bounces wrong on a bad spot. It's so frustrating. You're right that both tools have to work. One weak link ruins the whole process.