Is AI art really creating or just remixing? A debate I keep having
I was at a local gallery opening in Portland last month and saw two pieces side by side. One was done by hand over 3 weeks, the other by a guy who typed a prompt into Midjourney in 10 minutes. The AI piece won the crowd vote, and honestly it did look better. But that got me thinking: if the AI just pulled from millions of existing images, is that the same as what a human artist does when they learn from their influences? I lean toward saying intent matters more than the tool. What do you all think, does the source of the creativity change the value?