c/bakers

Rant: Local bakery charging $6 for a loaf that costs $1.20 to make

Heard a guy at a Charlotte bakery supply store bragging about his 300% markup on sourdough, saying customers won't know the difference. My business background says pricing has to cover rent and labor, sure, but $6 for flour, water, and salt feels steep when I can make 12 loaves for under $15. Is there a line between fair profit and just milking the artisan trend, or am I the weird one for thinking about costs? Anyone else bake at home and get annoyed at shop prices, or do you pay up for convenience?

0 comments

mark611•21h ago

Sourdough starter discard recipes are mostly a waste of flour

I kept seeing everyone rave about discard crackers and pancakes, so I tried about 6 recipes from a thread in Portland last month. Every single one tasted flat or overly tangy in a bad way, and I tossed half the batches. The only thing that worked was using discard to thicken a beef stew, which felt like cheating. Am I missing some secret discard trick or is it just hype?

0 comments

miabennett•1d ago

Took me 2 years to finally try cold proofing my dough in the fridge, wow

Always thought cold proofing was for fancy bakeries only. My loaves always came out flat and dense no matter how long I let them rise on the counter. Then I read a post here from someone in Portland who said they pop their shaped boules in the fridge for 18 hours. Tried it last Saturday with a simple white loaf. The crust got this deep caramel color and the inside was so open and airy. I used my regular recipe, same flour, same yeast. Just changed the proofing spot. Has anyone else had this big of a difference from one simple switch?

1 comments

jana_price•5d ago

Just realized my grandma's pie crust trick works every time, even after 40 years

She told me to freeze the butter and grate it into the flour, and after 6 failed batches at my shop in Portland last month, I tried it on a whim and now I can't go back, has anyone else had an old family tip that beat every fancy technique they tried?

0 comments

oscarmurphy•5d ago

The one critique that changed my sourdough starter routine

Back in 2019 a guy at the Portland farmers market told me my loaves were too dense and asked if I was feeding my starter twice a day. I had been doing once for about 5 years since I started baking at home. I switched to a 12 hour schedule with a 1:2:2 ratio at 78 degrees and the crumb opened up completely. Has anyone else had a random stranger spot something you missed for years?

0 comments

angelafisher•7d ago

My sourdough got better once I stopped kneading it

I spent a solid 15 months doing that whole stretch and fold routine every 30 minutes for 4 hours. Then I got lazy one Sunday and just mixed the dough, walked away, and baked it 8 hours later. The crumb was way better and I almost got mad about it. Guess I was overworking the dough this whole time, has anyone else found less handling gives better results?

0 comments

fox.skyler•10d ago

That $45 banneton was worth every penny, I used to think it was fake hype

I fought using a proofing basket for years, just used a mixing bowl and towel. Then I saw a 70% hydration dough hold its shape perfectly at a class in Chicago and finally bought one, now my loaves don't flatten out. Anyone else have a tool they resisted forever and then instantly regretted not buying sooner?

0 comments

davis.dakota•11d ago

Vent: sourdough starter took 23 days to actually work, not 7 like every recipe says

Every blog and book I read said 5 to 7 days and you'd have a bubbly starter ready to bake. I fed mine daily, kept it warm, used filtered water, did everything by the book. Day 8 it looked active, so I tried a loaf. Brick. Day 12, tried again. Another brick. Almost gave up and tossed the whole jar. Then on day 23, out of nowhere, it doubled in 6 hours and my bread finally had an open crumb. Turns out my tap water had chlorine that was killing the yeast slowly. Had to switch to bottled water. Anyone else have a starter that took way longer than the internet promised? How many days did yours take?

0 comments

dakota160•15d ago

One Tuesday last month almost made me quit baking for good

I had a 12 cake order for a wedding plus a bakery case to stock, all due by noon. The walk-in cooler decided to die at 4 AM, so my buttercream was soup and my dough was proofing way too fast. I spent $80 on emergency dry ice just to keep things cold, threw out one whole batch of croissants that overproofed, and somehow the wedding cake still came out lopsided. By 11 AM I was crying in the walk-in next to the dry ice, and the owner just said 'we all have days like this.' Has anyone else had a single shift that tested everything you had?

0 comments

reese_garcia•17d ago

That $300 proofing box was worth every penny in January

I run a small bakery out of my kitchen in Minneapolis. Last winter my dough was taking 6 hours to rise because the house sat at 60 degrees. I finally dropped $300 on a decent proofing box and it cut my rising time down to 2 hours. The temp control is way more steady than my oven with the light on. Anyone else using one, or do you have a cheaper setup that works just as good?

0 comments

lily_schmidt53•17d ago

The parchment paper edge trick my mother-in-law swore by

She cuts it about half an inch past the pan rim so you can grip it without burning your knuckles on the hot metal, and after 3 batches of cinnamon rolls last Sunday I finally see the point. My own method of folding it under just made everything slide around, so has anyone else adopted this or do you use some other grip system for heavy loaves?

1 comments

alice_wilson73•18d ago

Took 14 months to crack my sourdough starter issue in Austin

My starter kept turning hoochy and flat no matter what I did. Tried every ratio from 1:1:1 to 1:5:5, swapped flours like crazy, even bought a fancy proofing box from a shop on South Congress. Turned out my tap water had too much chlorine for the bacteria, switched to filtered and it took off in 3 days. Anyone else fight a simple fix for way too long?

1 comments

dylan_rodriguez•21d ago

Third try with tangzhong finally made a decent loaf

I've been chasing a fluffy sandwich bread for months and tried the tangzhong method at my place in Tacoma. First two batches came out dense and gummy, but yesterday I let the flour-water paste cool to 150 degrees instead of rushing it. The crumb was actually soft and held up for 3 days without going stale. Anyone else have to dial in the paste temperature before it worked for them?

0 comments

quinn603•21d ago

My old sourdough starter finally gave up after 8 years

Last week I went to feed my starter like every Friday morning and it just smelled off. Flat, no bubbles, the hooch turned dark. I keep it in a mason jar on my counter in Portland, fed it rye flour twice a week for 8 years straight. I tried reviving it with a warm water soak and fresh flour, but after three days it still had nothing. Has anyone else lost a long-running starter and just started over, or is there a trick I missed?

1 comments

bettyh84•21d ago

The weekend I took 14 cake orders and almost walked out of my own kitchen

Last Saturday I had 14 custom cakes lined up for a wedding expo in Tulsa, thought I had it all planned out. By noon the oven thermometer was reading 50 degrees off, my buttercream split twice, and one bride changed her design completely while I was mid-crumb coat. Part of me thinks doing the volume was the mistake, but the other part says I just got unlucky with prep and equipment. Anyone else have a day where the chaos made you question if big orders are even worth it?

0 comments

mila_sullivan•21d ago

My grandma's pie recipe called for 'a knob of butter' and I finally looked it up

I've been making her apple pie for 10 years, always just guessing with a pat or two. Last Tuesday I found an old note in the recipe box that said 'knob = about 2 tablespoons, ask your grandfather'. He passed in 2008 so tracking down that answer took a while. Turns out my pies were always fine, but now I know. Did anyone else grow up with vague measurements like this, or was my family just weird?

1 comments

lily_schmidt53•23d ago

Overheard a pro baker mention oven steam, my bread changed overnight

Last Saturday at the farmer's market stand, the guy next to me told a customer that home ovens dry out dough, so he throws ice cubes in a pan. I did that on my next loaf and the crust cracked like I finally had a real deck oven. Anyone else skip steam because they figured it was just commercial bakers?

1 comments

jana_miller31•26d ago

Took me 4 Saturdays to figure out my croissants were too warm, not underproofed

I kept getting these dense, flat croissants that looked like sad pancakes. I blamed my yeast, my flour, even my rolling technique. Swapped everything, still bad. Then I left a batch in the garage overnight because my kitchen was too hot, and they came out perfect. Turns out my kitchen stayed around 80 degrees in July, so the butter kept melting into the dough before it could layer. I bought a cheap thermometer for $9 and now I keep my mixing bowl on a cold pack during summer. Has anyone else chased the wrong problem for weeks only to find it was something dumb like temperature?

1 comments

grace_perry44•29d ago

Saturday market rush changed my pie crust game

Last weekend at the farmers market in Portland, I sold out of pies by 10am because I finally stopped overworking the dough. Turns out the cold butter chunks matter way more than the fancy pastry cutter I bought. Anyone else have a routine change that paid off bigger than expected?

1 comments

wren217•29d ago

The wedding expo demo that made me ditch laminated dough classes

Last month I did a live puff pastry demo at the Portland Expo and my dough cracked so bad the bride-to-be laughed out loud. I watched the guy next to me use a simple rough puff method and his results were flawless in half the time. Has anyone else found that the classic laminated method is only worth it for showpieces, not practical bakery output?

1 comments

robert_craig•29d ago

Sourdough starter vs commercial yeast, picked the starter and lost a week

Tbh I finally gave up on the wild yeast route after 9 days of flat, sticky loaves in my Portland kitchen. Switched back to instant yeast for Saturday's bake and got a decent crumb in 4 hours flat. Anyone else find starters just aren't worth the fuss unless you're baking daily?

1 comments

lisa_bennett•1mo ago

I finally had a perfect bake day, then the humidity ruined Sunday

Last Tuesday I did 6 batches of croissants and every single one came out with that perfect honeycomb crumb, which NEVER happens for me in my kitchen in Portland. I was riding that high, even sent photos to my cousin who bakes professionally. Then Sunday rolled around and the same recipe turned into flat, greasy discs because the air was so thick you could chew it. Has anyone else had a day where everything clicks, only to get humbled by the weather a few days later? How do you adjust your hydration when the forecast shifts like that?

1 comments

rowan593•1mo ago

A customer told me my pie crusts were too tough and I got defensive at first

She said they reminded her of store-bought, which stung because I make everything from scratch. Turns out I was overworking the dough and not letting the butter get cold enough - 3 minutes of extra mixing was the problem. Has anyone else had to unlearn a basic habit they thought was fine?

2 comments

the_joseph•1mo ago

My sourdough starter went 3 months before I figured out the mistake

Kept feeding it the same way every day. Discard, add flour, add water. But it never doubled. Just sat there bubbly but flat. My neighbor who runs a bakery in Denver asked what water I used. Tap water. She laughed and said the chlorine was killing my yeast. Switched to filtered water and popped it in the warmer part of the kitchen. Took about 4 days but it finally rose like crazy. Now I bake 2 loaves a week and they actually have oven spring. Anyone else fight with their starter for months before realizing something simple?

2 comments

wren217•1mo ago

Blew $150 on a fancy Dutch oven and it cracked on the second use

I figured a high-end enameled pot would last forever, but after one loaf of bread at 450 degrees, the bottom split right down the middle, has anyone else had luck with the cheaper Lodge ones instead?

1 comments